The Church of South India, Toronto has been blessed with having the following vicars serve over the years.
| Rev. Shaji M. Johnson | 2011- present |
| Rev. Raju Jacob | 2008 – 2011 |
| Rev. T. J. John | 2005 – 2008 |
| Rev. A. C. Cheriyan | 2000 – 2005 |
| Right Rev. K. Michael John | 1994 – 2000 |
| Rev. Shajan A. Idiculla | 1991 – 1993 |
| Rev. George M. John | 1987 – 1989 |
| Rev. Thomas Ninan | 1986 |